▶ Watch this video on YouTube ↗

Original video by @BrianLagerstrom — all credit to the creator.

Brian Lagerstrom

Fully Loaded Italian Deli Pasta Salad With Homemade Dressing

Soft rotini is seasoned with vinegar while hot, then folded with salami, Kalamata olives, sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, and coarse Parmesan. A creamy blended Italian dressing tastes like the one from a classic Italian-American restaurant.

⏱ 12 minabout 8 (more like 5-6 hungry eaters)Italian-Americanpasta saladitaliansalamihomemade dressingmake-ahead

Ingredients

Pasta Salad

  • 2000 gwater · about 2 qt
  • 45 gfine salt · for the pasta water
  • 235 grotini · or fusilli; 225-235 g
  • 25 gwhite distilled vinegar · for seasoning the hot pasta
  • 1-2 tspolive oil · for tossing the pasta
  • 100 gpitted Kalamata olives · cut into thirds; Castelvetrano for a milder option
  • 60-75 gred bell pepper · small diced (about half a pepper)
  • 50-75 gpepperoncini · small diced; use more for extra heat
  • 110 gthin-sliced Genoa salami · diced into 1-inch squares and fluffed apart; pepperoni or capicola also work
  • 150 gItalian dressing · homemade (below), plus more as needed
  • 100-150 gfresh mozzarella · firm cow's-milk ball, diced into 1/4-inch cubes; not buffalo mozzarella
  • 100 goil-packed sun-dried tomatoes · blotted and chopped into 1/2-inch pieces
  • 75 gaged Parmesan · coarsely grated, plus more for serving

Dressing

  • 20 gred onion · chopped and rinsed
  • 1 clovegarlic · about 5 g
  • 15 gred bell pepper · chopped
  • 25 ggrainy mustard
  • 25 gred wine vinegar
  • 45 gwhite distilled vinegar
  • 1/4 tspdried oregano
  • 1/4 tspdried basil
  • 1/4 tspred chile flake
  • 1/4 tspground black pepper
  • 15 gsugar
  • 5 gsalt
  • 200 gneutral oil · about 1 cup; canola, avocado, or peanut (not olive oil)

Steps

Creator's notes

Cook the pasta on purpose past al dente: the starch firms up once it's chilled, so soft pasta ends up with the right texture cold. Seasoning the hot pasta with vinegar works like seasoning sushi rice; it isn't meant to make it sour. Don't use olive oil in the dressing. Blending makes it bitter, and it solidifies in the fridge and then breaks. With a regular blender, make a double batch so the blades can catch everything. To make it by hand, chop the onion, garlic, and pepper into a fine paste, then whisk in the rest. The dressing keeps about 2 months refrigerated, and the salad keeps 3-4 days. The recipe makes extra dressing because the pasta soaks it up as it sits. Use thin-sliced salami and firm cow's-milk mozzarella; buffalo mozzarella is too soft and tears apart. Dry-packed sun-dried tomatoes can be soaked in hot water for about 3 hours, drained, and packed in oil. Coarsely grated 18-month aged Parmesan stays distinct instead of turning pasty.

More from Brian Lagerstrom

All recipes →